Workforce Development

Top 5 Employee Engagement Models Every Manager Should Know

Top 5 Employee Engagement Models Every Manager Should Know

Top 5 Employee Engagement Models Every Manager Should Know

Nikita Jain

Jun 16, 2025

Introduction: Why Employee Engagement Models Matter More Than Ever

In today’s dynamic and demanding business landscape, employee engagement has evolved into more than just a metric for tracking satisfaction—it has become a fundamental pillar of organizational success. As companies navigate hybrid work models, technological disruptions, and changing employee expectations, the ability to improve employee engagement consistently and effectively is what separates stagnant teams from a high performing team. It is within this context that an employee engagement model becomes indispensable.

An employee engagement model provides structure, clarity, and direction. Rather than guessing what motivates teams or relying on sporadic initiatives, managers and HR leaders can use an employee engagement model to ground their efforts in proven frameworks. This approach helps dissect complex human behaviors, uncover motivational drivers, and identify actionable areas for growth. By applying an employee engagement model, organizations can address both individual needs and collective dynamics with precision and empathy.

Click on Employee Engagement Software: Tools to Boost Staff & Workforce Productivity

Managers seeking to improve employee engagement often face common obstacles—unclear expectations, disconnected communication, and misaligned priorities. These challenges, left unaddressed, can slowly erode morale and productivity. However, when supported by a comprehensive employee engagement model, managers gain visibility into these friction points and the tools to resolve them effectively. The result is a consistent improvement in motivation, collaboration, and overall team output.

One of the most compelling advantages of implementing a structured employee engagement model is its ability to create and sustain a high performing team. While talent acquisition plays a crucial role, it’s ongoing engagement that unlocks performance. A high performing team is not only skilled but deeply aligned, motivated by purpose, and committed to shared goals. This level of engagement does not happen by accident—it is cultivated through deliberate practices that a robust employee engagement model can inform and guide.

Click on Top Employee Engagement Platforms for Teams, Talent & Workplace Success

Why Do Managers Struggle to Improve Employee Engagement?

Despite the growing emphasis on employee well-being and organizational culture, many managers still struggle to improve employee engagement in a meaningful, sustained way. The challenge isn’t a lack of concern—most leaders genuinely want to foster better environments for their teams. Rather, the struggle often stems from an absence of a structured, repeatable process. Without the guidance of a proven employee engagement model, even the most well-meaning managers are left to rely on fragmented efforts, guesswork, and short-term fixes that fail to drive lasting change.

One of the primary reasons managers fail to improve employee engagement is the misconception that engagement can be solved through isolated programs or periodic activities. A single pulse survey, a few town hall meetings, or a new wellness perk might boost morale temporarily, but they rarely shift the deeper dynamics that influence long-term engagement. Employee motivation and commitment are influenced by a complex mix of leadership behavior, workplace culture, communication, career development, and emotional connection to the company’s mission. Without an employee engagement model to bring structure and insight to these factors, efforts to improve employee engagement tend to be reactive, inconsistent, and disconnected.

Click on Cultural Alignment Action Plan: Drive Team Success

An effective employee engagement model gives managers a clear framework to identify what truly drives engagement within their teams. However, in many organizations, managers lack access to or training on how to apply such a model. This results in vague goals, limited visibility into engagement levels, and unclear expectations around what actions actually move the needle. Without a consistent employee engagement model to guide them, managers often fail to distinguish between symptoms of disengagement—like declining performance or absenteeism—and the underlying causes, such as lack of recognition, purpose, or autonomy.

Another major obstacle to improve employee engagement is poor feedback and communication practices. In the absence of an employee engagement model, feedback loops are often broken. Communication tends to flow one way—from the top down—without opportunities for employees to voice their needs, challenges, or ideas. This disconnect undermines trust and leaves employees feeling unheard. A high performing team thrives on transparency, open dialogue, and timely recognition—all of which are core components of a well-designed employee engagement model.

Click on Proven Change Enablement Strategies for Organisation Adoption

How to Determine When to Use an Employee Engagement Model

An employee engagement model should be introduced when:

  • Turnover rates are high or trending upward

  • Productivity is inconsistent or declining

  • Employee surveys reflect low morale, trust, or connection

  • Managers struggle to identify causes of disengagement

  • Leadership wants to build or sustain a high performing team

  • The organization is undergoing change, such as a merger, restructuring, or digital transformation

Using a structured employee engagement model allows managers to move beyond symptoms and address root causes. This ensures that any effort to improve employee engagement is not only timely but targeted and transformational.

Click on Why And How To Measure Employee Engagement (Or Else)

The Benefits of Using an Employee Engagement Model

Using an employee engagement model delivers clear advantages, including:

  • A shared vocabulary for engagement across HR, leadership, and teams

  • Data-backed strategies to improve employee engagement in specific areas

  • Enhanced manager capability to lead with empathy, clarity, and purpose

  • Better alignment between organizational strategy and employee experience

  • The ability to consistently build a high performing team

Each employee engagement model introduces a structured methodology that simplifies complexity and empowers action. When applied with consistency, these models become catalysts for cultural change and performance growth.

Click on How To Measure What Matters In Employee Engagement

The Top 5 Employee Engagement Models in 2025

1. Gallup’s Q12 Engagement Model

Gallup’s Q12 model is based on decades of global research and centers around 12 key elements that contribute to employee engagement. These include factors like knowing what’s expected, receiving recognition, and having opportunities to learn and grow. The Q12 survey is widely used because of its simplicity and its direct link to performance outcomes.

How it helps:
It allows managers to diagnose engagement at a granular level and initiate changes that resonate with core motivational needs.

Best for:
Organizations seeking a standardized, validated model that connects engagement to bottom-line results.

2. The Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) Model

The JD-R model explains engagement as the balance between job demands (like workload or emotional stress) and job resources (like support, autonomy, and feedback). The model emphasizes that high job demands lead to burnout, while rich job resources fuel engagement and resilience.

How it helps:
It equips managers with a dual-lens framework to reduce stressors while amplifying positive factors, leading to healthier work environments.

Best for:
Companies managing change, hybrid work, or burnout risks.

3. AON Hewitt Engagement Model

This model breaks engagement into three behavioral indicators: say (advocacy), stay (loyalty), and strive (discretionary effort). AON Hewitt's model then links these indicators to six key engagement drivers: leadership, performance, brand, work, basics, and company practices.

How it helps:
It delivers a well-rounded structure to improve employee engagement by targeting specific drivers that influence discretionary effort.

Best for:
Organizations that want to measure both behavioral outcomes and their root causes across departments or geographies.

4. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Applied to the Workplace

Maslow’s well-known theory of motivation is often adapted into an employee engagement model. It suggests that employees must have their basic needs met—such as job security and belonging—before they can pursue higher-level engagement, such as creativity, purpose, and leadership.

How it helps:
It offers a human-centered approach that allows managers to layer engagement strategies according to team maturity and individual needs.

Best for:
Companies investing in leadership development or inclusive work cultures.

5. The Zinger Model of Employee Engagement

David Zinger’s model includes ten blocks of engagement structured around achieving results, crafting meaningful work, building strong relationships, and activating energy. It blends psychological insights with practical action and underscores the role of personal connection and purpose.

How it helps:
It encourages managers to engage holistically—through vision, meaning, well-being, and results—leading to long-term cultural cohesion.

Best for:
Organizations focused on employee well-being and intrinsic motivation as drivers of performance.

How to Apply These Models to Improve Employee Engagement

While each employee engagement model is distinct, they share common actionable principles:

  • Assess first: Conduct surveys or interviews to understand where engagement currently stands. Use model-specific assessments like Gallup Q12 or JD-R diagnostics.

  • Identify key drivers: Each model pinpoints different engagement levers. Use insights to focus efforts where they’ll have the most impact.

  • Tailor strategies by team: Not every team will need the same approach. Use the models to localize solutions.

  • Equip managers: Train managers to understand the models and how to implement relevant changes in leadership behavior, communication, and feedback.

  • Monitor and iterate: Engagement is not a one-time fix. Use data to track progress, adapt strategies, and reinforce wins.

The key to improving engagement is consistent application and feedback loops. When managers are trained to apply these models with context and empathy, engagement evolves from a metric to a mindset.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Employee Engagement Model

In today’s competitive and constantly evolving workplace landscape, choosing the right employee engagement model is more than an HR exercise—it is a leadership imperative. With work environments becoming more distributed, workforce expectations changing rapidly, and organizational agility emerging as a critical factor in success, the importance of a strong, adaptable employee engagement model cannot be overstated. Every organization, regardless of its size or industry, needs a tailored strategy to improve employee engagement that aligns with its values, goals, and culture. This is where selecting and applying the right employee engagement model becomes essential.

While there are multiple frameworks available—each designed with a different focus, structure, and methodology—no single employee engagement model can guarantee success in isolation. What matters is how thoughtfully the model is chosen, how deeply it is integrated into leadership behaviors, and how consistently it is applied across all levels of the organization. Managers and HR leaders must view these models not as static templates, but as flexible guides that evolve with their teams. The real value of an employee engagement model lies in its ability to drive real-world outcomes—ones that meaningfully improve employee engagement and fuel the emergence of a high performing team.

A well-selected employee engagement model empowers managers to identify what truly motivates their people. It enables leaders to tap into the emotional, psychological, and professional needs of team members in a structured way, transforming engagement from a vague concept into a set of measurable, actionable practices. By using an employee engagement model to improve employee engagement, leaders can create a work culture where purpose, recognition, development, and trust are seamlessly embedded into daily operations.

Organizations aiming to build a high performing team must understand that high performance doesn’t stem solely from technical skills or productivity tools. Instead, it grows from deeply engaged individuals who feel valued, heard, and connected to a shared mission. An effective employee engagement model helps leaders nurture these foundational elements by offering a framework to listen, respond, and adapt. It translates employee feedback into strategy, links individual contribution to organizational goals, and promotes a sense of ownership across teams.

Moreover, the impact of the right employee engagement model extends far beyond individual engagement scores. It improves collaboration, accelerates innovation, reduces attrition, and strengthens the leadership pipeline. Teams that benefit from a consistently applied employee engagement model tend to be more resilient during change, more focused in execution, and more committed to long-term success. These are the hallmarks of a high performing team—and they are nurtured through intentional engagement practices.

Leaders who want to improve employee engagement should take the time to explore different types of employee engagement models, evaluate which align best with their organizational dynamics, and experiment with hybrid or customized versions when needed. Whether it’s a model focused on psychological needs, drivers of motivation, or engagement behaviors, what matters most is how effectively it is put into practice. An employee engagement model that sits in a handbook is of little use; one that is integrated into leadership training, performance management, and culture-building efforts becomes transformative.

In practical terms, improving employee engagement through a thoughtfully chosen employee engagement model requires a commitment to ongoing learning and adaptation. Engagement strategies must be revisited regularly, informed by data and feedback, and adjusted to meet the evolving needs of the workforce. Managers should be empowered with the right tools, coaching, and systems to operationalize the employee engagement model effectively and consistently.

As the connection between engagement and performance becomes increasingly clear, organizations must prioritize selecting and applying the employee engagement model that best supports their goals. A generic approach won’t yield exceptional results. The organizations that will thrive in the future are those that treat employee engagement not as a one-time initiative, but as a continuous leadership practice supported by a strong, adaptable employee engagement model.

Ultimately, the journey to improve employee engagement is a strategic one. When guided by the right employee engagement model, that journey leads to higher trust, greater alignment, and the sustained excellence of a high performing team. In an era where people are an organization’s greatest competitive advantage, leveraging the right model is not just a smart move—it is the key to unlocking full potential and long-term organizational success.

Click on Best Succession Planning Tools to Streamline Leadership Transitions

References

Drive Skill Growth at Scale With Smart AI Nudging

Learn More

Increase Learning Outcomes by

87%

and maximize your talent potential

Founder

Founder

Nikita Jain is a dynamic CEO and recognized leader passionate about harnessing technology and capability development to unlock the full potential of individuals and organizations. With over a decade of rich experience spanning enterprise learning, digital transformations, and strategic HR consulting at top firms like EY, PwC, and Korn Ferry, Nikita excels at driving significant, measurable success.