Managerial Effectiveness

Nikita Jain
Jul 8, 2025
Introduction
When you have ever been in a high performance team then you understand the magic, the ideas come very easily, there is ease in communication, and each team member somehow appears to be oriented towards achieving the team objectives. However, building a team like that is not an enchantment. It requires form, response, and a mutual dedication to development.
Click on Individual Development Plan for Employees (Template & Guide)
In goes performance improvement plan. A PIP should not be used as simply corrective action or to correct the performance of the underperformers as many people imagine. A performance improvement plan can be a most effective way of development when implemented carefully with the help of a well-planned pip template which is the one that enables individuals and whole teams to realize their potential.
In this blog, we discuss the field of performance improvement plans and how it can contribute to constructing high performing teams, and provide you with resources of some free (and credible) pip template resources that you may start using right now.
Click on What Are ERGs? Everything Leaders & Employees Should Know
What Is a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)?
A performance improvement plan is an official document that states which areas to improve, the expectations in terms of performance, and what the employee- or team can do to enhance it. It does also establish a time line and the resources or support that would be availed.
Click on Hiring Neurodiverse Talent: What Every Employer Should Know in 2025
Although the word tends to associate with anxiety, a PIP does not necessarily imply something red. When done in an empathetic and transparent manner, it is able to create a sense of engagement, motivation and accountability as significant elements as part of any high performing team.
SHRM said that under the correct use of performance improvement plans, behavior can be put back on track, expectations made clear, trust could be established or restored particularly when a foundation in development rather than discipline is made.
Click on 4 Steps to Make DEI a Core Component of Performance Evaluations
Why High Performing Teams Still Need PIPs
Even the best-in-the-business teams may buckle under a roadblocks-missed deadlines, misalignment within the team, a lack of clarity of expectations, or a lack of competencies. The performance improvement plan permits you to solve problems before they become entrenched as opposed to letting them brood.
An effective team does not imply perfection; it means advancement and receptiveness. PIP structure should be a thing that teams access as they have a map on how to course-correct. This does not only enhance productivity, but it fosters a learning and resilient culture.
Teams who practice reflection, review, and revision of their approaches have high probabilities to remain competitive and driven. An open, partnership approach to performance improvement can have a game-changing effect in that direction.
Components of a Strong PIP Template
The pre-designed pip template is cost- and time-efficient and helps to add consistency to the process of improvement. Depending on whether you are helping one employee or a full possession, a stable PIP has in any case:
Performance report : Actual performance as compare to the expected standards
Goals that need improvement: SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) objectives
Support Provided: Coaching, mentoring, training
Action Steps: Clear tasks that are goal oriented
Check-In Dates: Reviews with targets that indicate progress
Outcome Expectations:How success will be like and next steps possible
Click on The House Of Empathy: Cultivating High-Performing Teams And Organizational Excellence
Turning PIPs Into Growth Tools
To make the most of a performance improvement plan, leaders must use it as a coaching tool, not a control tactic. Here’s how:
Engage the team early: Don’t surprise employees with a PIP. Instead, hold honest conversations to co-develop the plan.
Set goals collaboratively: Involve the employee or team when drafting the action plan. This builds ownership and accountability.
Celebrate progress: Every milestone counts. Acknowledging effort and growth reinforces motivation and boosts morale.
Don’t wait for failure: Use a pip template proactively—not just reactively—when team performance starts slipping.
When used in this way, a performance improvement plan becomes a shared commitment to growth, not a threat.
Real Example: Marketing Team Turnaround
In a medium-sized online business, the marketing department would struggle to keep marketing campaigns consistent and create incidences of misunderstanding. Instead of restructuring the team, the management instituted a performance enhancement program on the team. With the help of a pip template provided by Smartsheet, they found weak areas (e.g. blurred content deadlines and no training on new tools of analytics) and developed SMART goals.
Their weekly check-ins were proposed, and training and documentations became clear. The campaign success rates rose by 35% in two months and the team morale has gone sky-high. Not only does the process enhance output, but it also made the team feel supported.
Conclusion
A performance improvement plan is not just about managing poor performance; it’s about helping good teams become great and great teams become unstoppable. With clarity, empathy, and the right resources, a PIP becomes more than just a form; it becomes a mindset.
If you’re a manager aiming to nurture a high-performing team or an HR leader developing organization-wide growth plans, the right PIP template can be a vital tool. Don’t wait for problems to arise; use performance improvement plans as part of your ongoing strategy to empower, support, and uplift your people.
Click on 5 Questions to Ask in a Stay Interview (That Actually Reveal the Truth)
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What is the purpose of a performance improvement plan?
A performance improvement plan (PIP) is designed to help employees or teams identify areas where performance is not meeting expectations and to provide a clear, supportive path toward improvement. It includes actionable goals, timelines, and the support required to meet those goals.
2. Is a PIP only for underperforming employees?
Not at all. While traditionally associated with underperformance, a performance improvement plan can also be a powerful development tool for anyone who needs clearer direction, structured coaching, or upskilling. In fact, many high-performing teams use PIPs proactively to stay aligned and sharpen focus.
3. Can a PIP be created for an entire team?
Yes. While most commonly used for individuals, teams can also benefit from a collective performance improvement plan—especially when collaboration, communication, or goal alignment is lacking. A team-wide pip template can outline group objectives, training needs, and metrics for success.
References
SHRM (2023). Performance Improvement Plans: Best Practices and Templates.
https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/employee-relations/pages/performance-improvement-plans.aspxBetterUp (2023). How to Build a PIP That Encourages Growth, Not Fear.
https://www.betterup.com/blog/performance-improvement-planSmartsheet (2023). Free Performance Improvement Plan Templates.
https://www.smartsheet.com/free-performance-improvement-plan-templatesIndeed (2023). Performance Improvement Plan: Guide and Template.
https://www.indeed.com/hire/c/info/performance-improvement-plan

Turn Top Talent into High-Impact Managers With AI
Learn More
Develop High-Performing Leaders
2x Faster
and drive measurable business results.
Nikita Jain is a dynamic CEO and recognized leader passionate about harnessing technology and capability development to unlock the full potential of individuals and organizations. With over a decade of rich experience spanning enterprise learning, digital transformations, and strategic HR consulting at top firms like EY, PwC, and Korn Ferry, Nikita excels at driving significant, measurable success.